Book a WhatsApp demo

Piece-Count Disputes in Garment Factories: Real Cases and How They Were Resolved

S
Santosh Rijal
· November 18, 2026 · 16 min read Bundle Tracking

Quick answer. Piece-count disputes are settled by records made when the pieces change hands, not by totals argued later. In the cases below, challans, invoices, ledgers and written acceptance decided the outcome; debit notes raised by one side alone and complaints raised months later did not. Count at the handover, by bundle, and put any shortage in writing that day.

Arguing over totals with a job worker or on payday? See bundle-level tracking on WhatsApp →

Not legal advice. The cases below are short summaries for learning. Laws differ by country, and the Indian district-court decisions may have been appealed.

Pieces change hands in three places in a garment business. An operator hands a finished bundle back to the line and expects to be paid for it. A factory sends cut panels out to a printer, embroiderer or stitching unit and expects the same number back. A factory packs cartons for a buyer and expects to be paid for every piece on the packing list. Each handover is a place where two people can end up with two different numbers.

This guide looks at how real count disputes in those three relationships were investigated and resolved, using published judgments and labour-agency releases. Payday arguments on the sewing floor and the four types of piece-rate dispute are covered in our guide to piece-rate disputes; what research says about piece-rate pay itself is in is piece-rate pay bad for garment workers?; and the cut-to-ship count arithmetic is in short shipments: why the carton count never matches the cut quantity.

What we found, and what we could not find

We read nine cases in full: two US Department of Labor releases, five Indian court decisions and two US federal court decisions. Two gaps are worth stating plainly. We found no published case in which a court recounted an operator's pieces, and no trial of a garment buyer's short-shipment claim against the factory on the packing list. Our reading is that most count disputes end at the factory gate or as a payment deduction, and never reach a court. The ones that do are decided on challans, invoices and ledgers, not on anyone's memory of a count.

Real cases: operator and factory

None of these three is a "count dispute" in the narrow sense. Two are US cases about piece-rate pay where the records were missing or falsified; the third is an Indian labour case in which a piece diary was part of the evidence.

1. Los Angeles Fashion District, 10 garment contractors (2012)

What happened. The US Department of Labor's Wage and Hour Division, working with the California Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, made unannounced inspections of a garment building at 830 S. Hill St. and found violations at all 10 contractors there. Investigators found "many garment employees were paid a piece rate — that is, paid for each piece they sewed or cut — without regard to minimum wage or overtime pay requirements", with average pay under $6.50 an hour, and "falsified time cards" (US DOL release, 13 December 2012).

How it was resolved. More than $326,200 in back wages for 185 employees. The division asked the contractors not to ship goods under the federal "hot goods" rule; several manufacturers that the contractors were producing for paid part of the back wages, and the objection to shipment was then lifted.

Lesson. When piece and time records are missing or false, the regulator rebuilds the numbers itself, and finished goods can be held until wages are paid.

2. Joe's Jeans and its contractor Angel's Finishing (2011)

What happened. A finishing contractor paid 110 workers "on a piece-rate basis without regard for minimum wage and overtime pay requirements for all hours worked, including some Saturdays and Sundays", and "weekend work was not recorded on employee time cards" (US DOL release, 10 January 2011).

How it was resolved. Joe's Jeans, the brand, paid $158,952 in back wages for a two-year period. It agreed to periodic monitoring of its contractors and a review of contract pricing so that contractors could afford to comply. The contractor and its owners were assessed $41,140 in civil money penalties for falsifying time records.

Lesson. Work that is never recorded is still owed, and in this case the customer paid it. Complete daily records protect both the factory and the brand it sews for.

3. Haridev Raut v. Ashok Jeans Factory (Delhi Labour Court, 2018)

What happened. A tailor said he was a monthly employee on Rs 20,000 and that Rs 23,500 in earned wages was unpaid. The jeans unit said he "used to work with it as a piece rate worker @ Rs.24 per piece", and before the Assistant Labour Commissioner it offered a balance of Rs 5,300 for pant pieces stitched, which he refused (LIR No. 1194/2018, award of 26 October 2018).

How it was resolved. The Labour Court found he was a piece-rate worker who had left on his own, and dismissed the petition. It did not decide the exact wage balance. The management said it was still willing to pay the Rs 5,300; the award does not say whether that was paid.

Lesson (our inference, not the court's). A daily count that both sides see and check was part of the factory's proof of how the worker was paid. But a diary held by the worker is thin evidence. A record the factory holds, timestamped and visible to the worker, would also have answered the Rs 23,500 versus Rs 5,300 question.

Real cases: factory and job-work subcontractor

These are the closest thing to a true "pieces sent versus pieces returned" dispute that we found. All three were decided by Delhi district courts, and all three turned on paperwork created at the time of the work.

4. Kamlesh Dhall (Horizons Inc) v. Inzex Global LLP: 365 "missing" printed pieces

What happened. A fabric-printing job worker billed Rs 21,76,764 for printing done in 2017 and was paid Rs 17,50,000. She sued for the Rs 4,26,764 balance. The principal said it had sent 59,441 pieces for printing and got back only 59,076, so 365 pieces were short, and that it had been overcharged against an alleged flat rate of Rs 25 a piece (CS (COMM) 18/2022, judgment of 20 July 2024).

How it was resolved. A Delhi commercial court held that, "as revealed from the invoices", the printer had printed 61,864 pieces, "because the defendants have also relied upon the same invoices". The principal had paid Rs 17,50,000 against the invoices "without protest", and before an email of 19.09.2017 it had never complained of short material. The court drew an adverse inference because the principal had "not initiated any legal action" over the 365 pieces. The printer was awarded Rs 4,26,764 with interest at 9% per annum (it had claimed 18%), plus costs.

Lesson. If pieces come back short, write the count on the return challan or goods-received note at the moment of receipt and tell the job worker in writing. Paying invoices without protest and complaining months later lost this principal both the shortage and the rate argument.

5. Libas Impex v. Sai Baba Overseas: kurtis given for fabrication, not returned

What happened. A ladies-garment business gave fabric to a fabricator under a written agreement, against seven job IDs and challans. Most of the goods never came back. The plaintiff sued on a cheque for Rs 92,72,539. The fabricator said the finished goods were ready and the plaintiff would not collect them or pay (CS (COMM) 257/2021, judgment of 5 July 2023).

How it was resolved. A Delhi commercial court limited the dispute to the seven challans the plaintiff's witness admitted. For each challan it took pieces sent minus pieces received back from the job-work account (on one challan, "number of pieces given for fabrication work are 1032 ... 628 + 178 pieces were received back ... The rest of the pending pieces were 226"), valued the shortfall per piece from the challan value, and added it up. The decree was for Rs 15,58,644 with 12% simple interest, not the Rs 92.7 lakh claimed. The fabricator's "the goods are ready" defence failed because it had no document to show it.

Lesson. The per-challan ledger (sent, received back, pending) is what the court used to work out the money. A claim larger than the challans support gets cut down, and a job worker who says "come and take the goods" needs written proof of that offer.

6. Print Fab India v. Richa Global Exports: 354 and 485 "rejected" pieces

What happened. A garment printer did job work for an exporter in 2006–07 and sued in 2009 for the unpaid balance. The exporter counter-claimed Rs 6,38,700.39 on debit notes: one for 354 rejected pieces of one style, one for 485 pieces of another, for "sub-standard" printing, and others for air freight on late shipments (CIV DJ 611394/2016 with Counter Claim 39/2024, judgment of 22 August 2024).

How it was resolved. A Delhi district court called the debit notes "unilaterally prepared documents [that] cannot be taken as a substitute for evidence", noting "no evidence to show that the debit notes were communicated or handed over to the plaintiff". The exporter's witness admitted that no document showed the goods were of inferior quality. The printer got a decree of Rs 18,58,128 with 12% interest from its legal notice of 09.04.2009, plus costs, and the exporter's counter-claim was dismissed.

Lesson. A rejection counts only if it is documented when it happens: the rejected pieces, an inspection record, a note sent to the job worker and, ideally, the job worker's acknowledgment.

Real cases: factory and buyer

None of these is a buyer suing a factory over short pieces. They are the nearest published cases: an importer against a shipping line over missing cartons, a supplier against a buyer over chargeback debit notes, and an exporter whose "the buyer said it was short" defence failed.

7. Judy-Philippine, Inc. v. S/S Verazano Bridge: 126 cartons missing on arrival

What happened. A US importer of children's garments received four containers from Hong Kong, stuffed and sealed at the factory, with 126 cartons missing in total, for example "container HDMU-4036180: 66 cartons worth $14,288.93". It sued the ocean carriers, first for $34,514.45 and later for $66,852.00 (805 F. Supp. 185, S.D.N.Y., 23 October 1992).

How it was resolved. Liability had already been decided in the importer's favour in 1991. In 1992 the court applied the US Carriage of Goods by Sea Act limit to "each of the 1,542 cartons rather than to the four containers, because the bills of lading expressly describe the contents of each container in terms of cartons". The final damages figure is not on the readable page.

Lesson. Get the carton count onto the bill of lading and packing list, not just "one container, said to contain". Carton-level documents decided both liability and how much could be recovered.

8. Weihai Lianqiao v. A Base IX: the buyer's chargeback debit notes

What happened. A Chinese apparel maker sued its US importer for about $4.2 million in unpaid invoices. The importer had issued many debit notes, several about cartons and pack counts: $312 because "Plaintiff incorrectly packed twenty-four items in a carton instead of twelve items in a master carton", $4,870 for 974 damaged cartons at $5 each, and $41,616 for hanger headers that said "three-pack" on goods ordered as two-packs (9,792 sets) (21 Civ. 10753, S.D.N.Y., 21 July 2025).

How it was resolved. After a bench trial the court gave judgment for the manufacturer: $4,189,136 plus $1,517,374.17 pre-judgment interest on the contract claim, with the importer's counter-claims dismissed. The court would "not take at face value the claims in the Debit Notes themselves". Only the two debit notes the seller had accepted in writing ($6,298 in total) were deducted. Even on the wrong pack-count labels, where a breach was shown, the importer recovered nothing because it gave no reasonable way to calculate its loss.

Lesson. Do not sign a buyer's debit note for pack-count or carton problems unless it comes with evidence. Keep the PO, packing list and carton specification so you can show what was ordered against what is claimed.

9. Hellmann Worldwide Logistics v. P C Global Merchandising: "the buyer reported short shipment"

What happened. A readymade-garment exporter's post-dated cheques to its freight forwarder bounced. Part of its defence was that the foreign buyer had reported short shipments and issued debit notes (CC No. 2125/17, judgment of 18 November 2019).

How it was resolved. A Delhi court rejected the plea: "No specific instance of any short delivery of shipment has been provided". The exporter's director "does not remember the airway bills of those shipments, where there was shortage", and admitted that all export shipments were delivered to the buyer. The company and its two directors were convicted for the dishonoured cheques.

Lesson. A short-shipment claim is only as strong as its link to a specific airway bill or bill of lading, carton count and packing list.

What evidence decides a piece-count dispute?

Records made at the handover decide it: challans with piece counts, invoices both sides relied on, matching ledgers, and written acceptance or written complaint at the time. In these nine cases, totals argued later, debit notes one side raised alone, and claims not tied to a specific challan, bundle or bill of lading did not hold up.

The nine cases at a glance: what decided each one
Case Relationship What decided it
LA Fashion District (2012)Operators and contractorsInvestigators rebuilt hours; the contractors' records were falsified
Joe's Jeans / Angel's Finishing (2011)Operators and contractorWeekend work missing from time cards
Haridev Raut v. Ashok Jeans (2018)Operator and factoryPiece diary checked against finished goods; the worker's own complaint
Kamlesh Dhall v. Inzex Global (2024)Factory and printerInvoices both sides relied on; payment without protest; late complaint
Libas Impex v. Sai Baba Overseas (2023)Factory and fabricatorPer-challan pieces sent and received back
Print Fab India v. Richa Global (2024)Exporter and printerInward and outward challans; uncommunicated debit notes failed
Judy-Philippine v. Verazano Bridge (1992)Importer and carrierCarton counts on the bills of lading
Weihai Lianqiao v. A Base IX (2025)Supplier and buyerWritten acceptance of debit notes; no proof of cost
Hellmann v. P C Global (2019)Exporter and forwarderNo airway bill or quantity linked to the shortage

Is a debit note proof of short or rejected pieces?

Not on its own, in the two courts that ruled on it. A Delhi district court called rejection debit notes "unilaterally prepared documents" in Print Fab India, and a New York federal court in Weihai Lianqiao deducted only the debit notes the seller had accepted in writing. A debit note needs the inspection record, counts and cost evidence behind it.

These are holdings of two courts in two jurisdictions, not a rule everywhere. But the pattern points one way: the side that documents the count and the rejection at the time, and gets the other side to see it, is the side whose number survives.

A SIMULATED case, step by step: 36 printed panels short

This case is SIMULATED. It is made up to show how bundle-level records change an investigation. The quantities are internally consistent; the money is illustrative.

A knit factory sends one lot of cut front panels to an outside screen printer on job work: 2,400 front panels, as 100 bundles of 24 pieces, each bundle with its own QR and bundle number (B-001 to B-100). They go out on one numbered delivery challan that lists all 100 bundle numbers.

The printed panels come back. The factory's receiving count is 2,364. The printer's invoice says 2,400 printed and returned, and bills print charges on 2,400. The factory says 36 are short; the printer says "we returned everything you sent". With only totals, that is the whole argument: 2,400 against 2,364, and nobody can say where the 36 are.

The investigation with bundle-level records

  1. Scan every returned bundle at the gate against the 100 bundle numbers on the challan.
  2. Read the result by bundle. 97 bundles are complete (97 × 24 = 2,328). B-041 has 20 pieces (4 short). B-077 has 16 pieces (8 short). B-063 did not come back at all (24 pieces). 2,328 + 20 + 16 = 2,364. Short = 4 + 8 + 24 = 36.
  3. Send the printer three bundle numbers, not a total. The printer checks: the 12 short pieces from B-041 and B-077 were misprints set aside at the printer, and bundle B-063 is found on their drying rack.
  4. The printer returns B-063 (24 pieces) and the 12 misprinted panels physically, for counting. All 2,400 are accounted for: 2,364 + 24 + 12 = 2,400.
Simulated case: the 100 bundles sent to the printer and what came back
Bundles Pieces sent Pieces returned at the gate Short Where the short pieces were
97 complete bundles2,3282,3280–
B-04124204Misprints set aside at the printer
B-07724168Misprints set aside at the printer
B-06324024Whole bundle on the printer's drying rack
Total (100 bundles)2,4002,36436–

Illustrative settlement (simulated; real terms depend on your job-work agreement):

Print charge at an illustrative Rs 6.00 per piece: the printer billed 2,400 × 6 = Rs 14,400. Payable on the 2,388 good panels (2,364 + 24): 2,388 × 6 = Rs 14,328.

Misprints, if the agreement makes the printer liable for them: 12 × an illustrative panel cost of Rs 95 = Rs 1,140.

Time: settled in a day, because the claim named bundles. A totals-only argument can drag on.

What the simulated case shows:

How do you settle a piece-count dispute? A checklist

Find the last point where both sides agreed the count, then compare records bundle by bundle from there. Put the difference in writing with bundle, challan or bill of lading numbers, ask for the physical pieces, including rejects, to be returned and counted, and settle on documents that both sides saw at the time.

Operator and factory

Factory and job worker

Factory and buyer

How Scan ERP handles this

Scan ERP was built in our own knit factory in Nepal, so it records the things these cases turned on:

It does not have a separate dispute log, job-work module or buyer-claim module. For how QR bundle records replace paper tickets, see QR bundle tags for garment production.

Sources

This article summarises published decisions and official guidance for learning. It is not legal advice. Laws differ by country, the Indian district-court decisions are not binding precedent and may have been appealed, and you should take advice from a lawyer on any live dispute.

Settle Counts by Bundle Number, Not by Totals

Scan ERP records every bundle at each station with the operator and the time, shows operators their own work and payments, and flags completed work with no payment entry. Ask the founder on WhatsApp and see it on a real line.

Ask on WhatsApp Request a Free Demo

Citing this reference

In nine published garment cases (US labour-agency actions, Indian district and labour courts, US federal courts), piece-count and shortage disputes were decided on records made at the handover: challans with piece counts, invoices both sides relied on, ledgers and written acceptance. Debit notes raised by one side alone and complaints raised months later did not hold up.

Copy this attribution

Scan ERP — Piece-Count Disputes in Garment Factories: Real Cases. https://scanerp.pro/blog/piece-count-disputes-garment-factory-cases.html

Free to reproduce with attribution. Last reviewed 18 November 2026.